Yes, this is not a drill. I am actually posting a TTT! The last time I actually participated in this was way back in January of 2023. But I saw this topic and, me with my petty, kneejerk dnf’s, loved the thought of it. So, as always, Top Ten Tuesdays are hosted by ThatArtsyReaderGirl.
So, today’s topic is: Petty Reasons You’ve DNF’d a Book (Or reduced its rating. You don’t even have to say what the book was if you don’t want to!) And with how I can be petty like no ones business when it comes to DNFing books… This should be fun.
I would like to note that, after actually looking through my DNF’d shelf on Goodreads that the extreme majority of book were DNF’d because of bad romances, rape-y undertones, creepy boyfriends/girlfriends. Knowing how knee-jerk I can be to anything that doesn’t feel 100% right in romance, I am not surprised. However, none of those books are on this list, because I do not feel that wanting things to be 100% consensual in romances is petty, but, rather, the bare minimum that I demand.
The story starts in the future, well past the time of the main events, from the sound of it, with a storyteller telling us the story of Kindred and the events in this book. And the storyteller has sections throughout the book (at least one I found by flipping through the pages) and one at the very end.
This is used as a framing device – one which I hate. So, yeah, it was DNF’d before I hit the double digits.
I didn’t like the head-hopping, but also very nit-picky and petty: I do not like going from dinner with the victim to their funeral. There is no discovering the dead body or any of the stuff that I am so used to happening to drag the sleuth/s into the case. This is just dinner one page, funeral the next and…meh.
I am a very soft heart when it comes to animals. I hate the way so many fantasy books (and games, but that’s another subject) has animals as mook fights.
This book has the main character rescue a puppy, only for the little girl who’s family apparently owns the dog to, in all seriousness, announce that they are going to eat the dog.
I don’t know if they do or not. I didn’t make it that far. This will always be a case of Schrodinger’s dog in my mind. (The puppy is both eaten and not, all at the same time!)
Sometimes when you decide to mostly borrow books from your library instead of spending hard earned cash on them, it means you are left waiting years before they get the book.
Or, you have to listen to it as an audio book when that is, literally, your least favorite form of ‘reading’ because that is the only format they have the book in. And sometimes that means that the audio book that you just finished – which was a major struggle – and the one you just picked up has the same narrator.
And you cannot subject yourself to that voice without remembering the worst things about the last book you listened to.
I’m going to be honest with you: I went through a phase in my life that foul language was sort of a death knell for any form of entertainment. (Hard to believe now, I know.)
Anyway, I don’t remember anything about this book other than what my Goodreads ‘review’ says, stating that the cursing in the book caused me to drop it. That being said, I really have the feeling that something else was at play, too, but I don’t know and even though I think I still own the book, I don’t intend on finding out.
The writing style of this book is set up so that it appears one of the girls is the author of the book and is currently writing it. Filled with asides from the other girls as you are reading. Asides that totally detract from the story and disturb the flow.
Which was, apparently enough for me at the time to drop the book, though to be honest, I forgot I even attempted to read it.
This book is an interesting case of DNF’ing as I didn’t stop reading it because of anything to do with this book.
Rather, what happened was I was loving the book so much that I wanted to check out if the sequel followed the same characters – only to discover the sequel has a romance that features cheating cheaters who cheat. (Which is 1000% a no go for me.)
My petty reason for dropping this book is, at its core, because it opens with the main female character in bed with her husband after having an amazing round of sex, telling us about how great the sex was.
A little more depth to my pettiness is that I started reading what I thought would be an amazing, feminist historical sci-fi but what was actually a poorly disguised chick-lit.
This is a soulless version of The Last Airbender world.
It might have worked as an original fantasy (maybe with a different author) but this is not the world that so many people have come to know and love. Or the world that I have come to know and mostly tolerate.
Would like to state that my pettiness for this book knows no bounds. Seriously.
‘Marvel’ in name only to jump on a cash cow, meanwhile completely wrecking three characters for this story. (Loki, Thor and Frigga.)
But, really, the deal breaker was this author (whom I have grown to detest for many reasons) stating in an interview: When I really sort of let go of that and stopped doing research and reading other people’s version. […] when I sort of let go of other people’s ideas about him and looked at him as not a character that has existed in this franchise […] that was what really made all the difference.
Honestly, it’s not often I get to say this, but: reads like bad fan fiction. Fan fiction so bad that the author doesn’t even try – or care to try – to make sure the character they are writing about bears a resemblance to the franchise character.
This was actually…disturbingly fun to put together. (And I probably could have stretched this out to another 5-8 petty DNFs.) Anyway, it did remind me of several books I had forgotten – not the last one, though, as my pettiness towards it will never be forgotten.